(This article was presented at the international seminar organized by Davangere
University and originally published in ‘Literary Endeavour’- UGC approved
international refereed journal. Vol. X-II April 2019. Edited by: Prof.P.Kannan)
(Reviewed by: Prof.Monica Ranjana, Principal, Government First Grade College, Hitnal, Koppal District)
(Reviewed by: Prof.Monica Ranjana, Principal, Government First Grade College, Hitnal, Koppal District)
INTRODUCTION:
Girish Karnad, a prominent name in Indian
English literature, dramatist with his own new fresh ideas, actor, film
director and Jnanapeetha awardee for his literature in Kannada, born in
Matheran of Maharashtra and brought up and studied in Dharwad of Karnataka. He
has the ability to surprise his readers with an immaculate way of presenting
ideas and facts through his dramas. It has been proven in his earlier,
especially historical dramas like Tughlaq, Taledanda and The
Dreams of Tipu Sultan.
Girish
Karnad’s new drama “Rakshasa Tangadi’ was published on
the eve of India’s independence in 2018. It is a two-act play with 12 scenes in
it. The drama deals with the causes and consequences to the fall of the
Vijayanagara Empire, which was the wealthiest empire in the world at that time
in all means. It is soon to be published in English under the title “Crossing
to Talikota”
BACKGROUND OF THE DRAMA:
Vijayanagara Empire- the wealthiest and the richest empire of the world in all
means, and had the strongest army, fell in mere a day in the Battle of Talikota
or Rakkasagi-Tangadagi Battle. There are many books to study this rich history
of Vijayanagara Empire. Many of the historians including Indian historians
followed the work- ‘A Forgotten Empire’ by the British
historian Robert Sewell which was originally published in 1900. It has become a
Bible for all of those who are interested in studying the history of
Vijayanagara.
But this
drama is constructed on the basis of the works done by two major historians-
Prof. Richard M. Eaton of Arizona USA and Dr. Krishna Kolhara Kulkarni of
Vijayapura, who has done a great work in collecting and interpreting the
original manuscripts written by Vijayanagara historians like Shiraji, Zubairi,
and Harikare. In this drama, Girish Karnad breaks the the stereotypic
attitude of study towards the Vijayanagara Empire and that’s why I have given
the title – A Retake on the Fall of Vijayanagara Empire.
INTRODUCTION TO THE TITLE OF THE DRAMA:
Through the study of history it is believed
that the final battle which led to the fall of Vijayanagara took place
somewhere near Talikote on the banks of river Krishna. It is also believed that
the exact place of battle is between the two villages namely Rakkasagi and
Tangadagi which is also known as Rakshasa Tangadi.
Girish
Karnad, in an interview regarding the discussion of this drama, says about the
uniqueness of the title Rakshasa Tangadi. The last battle of the Vijayanagara
Empire was against the four sultanates of the north- Bidar, Golkonda,
Vijayapura and Ahmed Nagar. It is glorified as a battle between Hindu-Muslim
empires. The title of this drama also depicts the same meaning- Rakshasa is a
Sanskrit word and Tangadi is an Urdu word.
ABOUT THE DRAMA- A RETAKE ON THE FALL OF VIJAYANAGARA EMPIRE:
This
drama is an eye-opener in many ways. Especially to those who still strongly
believe that Muslims invaded over Hampi and it was a Hindu-Muslim battle. It is
important for all of us to know the place of the battle before we come to the
conclusion that the Sultans invaded Hampi.
COMPLEXITY OF THE BATTLE:
The Vijayanagara Empire situated to the south
and five sultanates, which were predominantly ruling under the Vijayanagara
Empire, Bijapur, Ahmednagar, Bidar, Golkonda and Birar are to the north. The
river Krishna divides Vijayanagara from the Sultanates. The major question we
have to ask ourselves through this drama is, if the Sultanates invaded over
Vijayanagara, the battle should have taken place near Hampi or near the banks
of river Tungabhadra. But the battle took place on the banks of river Krishna
which clearly indicates that it is the emperors of Vijayanagara who invaded the
Sultanates of the north. More than a Hindu vs. Muslim battle, it was a
humanitarian battle between Aliya Ramaraya and the Sultans of the North. There
are many reasons for this battle which led to the fall of the Vijayanagara
Empire, which are revealed to us by this drama.
Map courtesy: http://www.aarde.in/
UNION OF SULTANS:
Five years before the battle, Bijapur’s Ali
Adil Shah visited Hampi and accepted Aliya Ramaraya as his stepfather, as Aliya
Ramaraya loses his son in an untimely death. This soothes Aliya Ramaraya, who
later, hands over the fort of Kalyana from Ahmadnagar’s Hussain Nizamshah to
Ali Adil Shah of Bijapur. It is his game plan to control all the sultans of the
North and Nizam Shah is furious about this. But Nizam Shah is helpless as he is
suffering from a longtime illness and has no army power to face Vijayanagara.
At this point, Begum of Ahmednagar gives an idea to Nizam Shah to save Kalyana
fort from being handed over to Bijapur Sultan. The idea from Begum is- instead
of handing over the fort, they can gift the fort to Ali Adil Shah by making him
the son in law. Nizam Shah’s first daughter is beautiful and she is sure that
Ali Adil Shah will not deny the offer. She also suggests to Nizam Shah that it
is the right time to bring unity among all the sultans against Aliya Ramaraya-
who is continuously playing games between all the sultanates and not allowing
them to unite. Although Nizam Shah denies this idea initially, he accepts this
later.
THE CHARACTER OF ALIYA RAMARAYA:
The central the character of this drama is
Aliya Ramaraya who is never the king of Vijayanagara Empire but who has all the
control over it. Ramaraya is the loving son in law of the great
Krishnadevaraya, who recognized by understanding the administrative strengths of
Ramaraya, gives his first daughter Satyabhama in marriage to him.
Though he
gets married to Satyabhama Tuluva dynasty never allows him to the throne of
Vijayanagara, which constantly haunts Ramaraya. After the death of Krishnadevaraya,
Sadashivaraya comes to the throne and Ramaraya, the minister and the general of
the Vijayanagara army, takes control over the empire and makes him the puppet
king.
As
always, great warriors keep their moves to themselves; Ramaraya becomes an
enigmatic character to himself, to his family members, to his people, and to
the Sultans. There is a constant battle in himself about the insults he is facing
for being “the Aliya” of Krishnadevaraya and never becoming the emperor of
Vijayanagara. He expresses that many times in the drama especially in scene 8
of act II.
Aliya
Ramaraya is a great warrior and a great administrator. His never dying spirit
to win wars for Vijayanagara Empire makes him even stronger and his enemies
even weaker. In the battle of Talikota, he himself leads the army of
Vijayanagara in the battlefield at the age of 82! But sometimes his
over-enthusiasm makes him ignore the strengths of the ultimate warriors in his
brothers Tirumala and Venkatadri.
Ramaraya
always longs for his past as he believes that he belongs to the Chalukya Dynasty
of Kalyana. That is why he is so possessive about the fort of Kalyana which is
the central element of conflict among the Sultans. He always wants to take control
over Kalyana fort and because it is outside his empire, he keeps rotating the
possession of the fort between Sultans, which makes them angry and they all
unite against him.
THE BATTLE:
There are
many reasons for the battle of Talikota between Vijayanagara and Sultanates of
the north. Importantly the game is being played by Ramaraya between the Sultans
in the issue of possession of Kalyana Fort. Ahmadnagar’s Nizam Shah never wants
to hand over the key of the fort to Ali Adil Shah of Bijapur. Ramaraya
interferes in the issue and beheads the general of Bidar army Zahangir Khan who
was taking care of Ahmednagar in the absence of Nizam Shah on his request to
Bidar Sultan which makes Nizam Shah even angrier and eventually as per his
wife’s suggestion he agrees for the marriage of his first daughter with Ali
Adil Shah of Bijapur and the second daughter with Ibrahim Kutub Shah of
Golkonda. More than the marriage they plan to unite against Vijayanagar. These
marriages eventually anger Ramaraya and he calls for the war against the
Sultanates.
In the
war, at the age of 82, Aliya Ramaraya leads the army of Vijayanagar, even in
the presence of Venkatadri and Tirumala. Ramaraya is so confident of winning
the war; he did not even keep an army battalion to take care of Hampi in their
absence when the battle is being waged at the banks of river Krishna.
Vijayanagara army is an ancient one with elephants, horses. And sultans’ army
is of modern weapons. All the sultans need to do is to allow Ramaraya to
crossover the river Krishna which he eventually does. Ramaraya is not fighting
the battle. Instead, he sits on a palanquin and encourages his soldiers to
fight for the glory of the Vijayanagara. Tirumalaraya gets wounded in the
battle and flees away from the battlefield which was the biggest setback to the
Vijayanagara army. Ultimately, Roomi Khan, the commander of Ahmadnagar catches
Ramaraya, who falls from the palanquin, and takes him to Nizam Shah. Nizam Shah
beheads Ramaraya in front of his stepson Ali Adil Shah.
THE FALL OF VIJAYANAGARA EMPIRE- WHO STARTED THE LOOT?
As soon
as Tirumalaraya gets hurt and flees out of the battlefield, he runs back to
Hampi, with the news of Ramaraya being killed by sultans. He initiates the
collection of all the wealth of the empire on the backs of 1500 elephants and shifts
to Penugonda, which is the next capital of Vijayanagara. The people of Hampi,
who hears the news of the defeat of their army in the battle, start to roar and
collects their wealth which is hidden the basements of their homes and run away
from Hampi. Even before the Sultans’ army reaches Hampi, half of the Hampi is
looted by their own people for the purpose of their security or for the fear of
their insecurity.
CONCLUSION:
After reading this drama, I am exposed to more
than one dimension to the fall of Vijayanagara Empire. There are more facets to
the battle, not just a battle between a Hindu empire and the Muslim Sultans.
The battle starts when Ramaraya is denied an access to the throne by Tuluvas
just because he belongs to the lower dynasty of all the dynasties who rule
Vijayanagara. The battle is inside Ramaraya who is longing for the fort of
Kalyana as he believes he belongs to Kalyana Dynasty. The battle begins when
Begum of Ahmednagar gives ‘Lady Macbethish’ idea to Sultan Nizam Shah to
arrange the marriage of their daughters with Ali Adil Shah of Bijapur and
Ibrahim Barid Shah of Golkonda. The battle begins when Ramaraya doesn’t
understand the offer of Ali Adli Shah to accept him as his stepson. The drama,
in the end, holds the message that the battle is not merely between religions.
It is between selfishness, untrustworthiness, insults, human disbeliefs,
overconfidence, and betrayal.
Eventually, it is the battle which ends the most the powerful and uncrowned king of Vijayanagara Empire Aliya Ramaraya because of: “The overwhelming confidence in his power, ignoring his enemies despite the fact that they are growing, nobody understands his politics, over-e nthusiastic to his probable source dynasty which made him forget his duty, disbelief in his own people; and believing those who are not worthy of believing… these are the causes to the fall of the unrivaled empire of the southern plateau - Vijayanagara and its last commander ‘Aliya Ramaraya'.
Eventually, it is the battle which ends the most the powerful and uncrowned king of Vijayanagara Empire Aliya Ramaraya because of: “The overwhelming confidence in his power, ignoring his enemies despite the fact that they are growing, nobody understands his politics, over-e nthusiastic to his probable source dynasty which made him forget his duty, disbelief in his own people; and believing those who are not worthy of believing… these are the causes to the fall of the unrivaled empire of the southern plateau - Vijayanagara and its last commander ‘Aliya Ramaraya'.
REFERENCES:
2. Why I wrote Rakshasa Tangadi? Girish Karnad | ನಾನೇಕೆ ರಾಕ್ಷಸ ತಂಗಡಿ ಬರೆದೆ?-ಗಿರೀಶ್ ಕಾರ್ನಾಡ್, YouTube, TheState.News, 15-08-2018
3. Bangalore Literature Fest:
1. https://youtu.be/vbS5ql6s2ss
2. http:// bangaloreliteraturefestival. org/crossing-to-hampi-a- dramatic-exploration-of-the- vijayanagara-catastrophe/
1. Karnad Girish, Rakshasa Tangadi, Dharwad, Manohara Granthamala, 2018, Print
2. Why I wrote Rakshasa Tangadi? Girish Karnad | ನಾನೇಕೆ ರಾಕ್ಷಸ ತಂಗಡಿ ಬರೆದೆ?-ಗಿರೀಶ್ ಕಾರ್ನಾಡ್, YouTube, TheState.News, 15-08-2018
Part 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxFICTcVVcU
Part 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8hnl1Ml34E
Part 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8hnl1Ml34E
3. Bangalore Literature Fest:
1. https://youtu.be/vbS5ql6s2ss
2. http://
Good article sir
ReplyDelete